Tuberculosis Patient’s Tragic Death Sparks Negligence Claims

Tuberculosis (TB) patient in Uttar Pradesh’s Budaun district died by suicide at a medical college hospital, with his family alleging medical negligence as the cause. The incident has raised concerns about patient care and the responsibilities of healthcare institutions in preventing such tragedies.

On December 6, at approximately 8:40 a.m., Subhash jumped from a window of the hospital ward. This occurred shortly after his father had left to visit the medicine counter. Prior to this, Subhash had been disturbed by the death of a neighboring patient, which may have influenced his mental state.
Dr. Neha, the principal in charge of the medical college, stated that Subhash had been battling tuberculosis for the past eight months and was admitted to the hospital on December 4 at approximately 5 p.m.

Incident Details

The patient, identified as Subhash, had been battling tuberculosis for eight months. He was admitted to the medical college hospital on December 4, 2024, around 5 p.m. Dr. Neha, the principal in-charge of the medical college, noted that Subhash had previously been admitted for TB treatment but had discontinued the regimen midway.

Police Investigation Underway

The local police have launched an investigation into the matter. They are reviewing CCTV footage from the hospital and interviewing both staff and family members to ascertain the sequence of events. The post-mortem report is awaited, and further action will be taken based on the findings.

Hospital’s Response

Dr. Neha acknowledged Subhash’s medical history and his previous non-compliance with the TB treatment regimen. However, specific details regarding the hospital’s response to the family’s allegations have not been disclosed.

This incident highlights the complex interplay between patient autonomy, medical responsibility, and legal accountability. In cases where patients die by suicide, especially within medical facilities, families often pursue legal action alleging negligence. However, establishing liability is challenging. Courts typically require proof that the healthcare provider’s actions were a direct cause of the patient’s death.

Moreover, the duty of care owed by healthcare providers is scrutinized in such cases. Providers are expected to assess suicide risk adequately and implement preventive measures. Failure to do so can result in legal claims. However, the inherent unpredictability of suicidal behavior complicates these assessments. A study in the Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law discusses the challenges in attributing liability, noting that not all suicides are preventable and that effective treatment often involves calculated risks.

Broader Issues Highlighted

This incident brings to light the critical gaps in the healthcare system, particularly regarding mental health support for patients with chronic illnesses. Tuberculosis is not only a physically debilitating disease but also a condition that significantly impacts mental health. Patients often face stigma, isolation, and emotional distress, which can exacerbate their psychological struggles.

Experts have stressed the need for hospitals to incorporate mental health evaluations and counseling as part of the treatment plan for patients with long-term illnesses. Ensuring constant monitoring and providing psychological support can help prevent such tragedies.

Preventive Measures Needed

To address such incidents, healthcare institutions must adopt the following measures:

1. Enhanced Monitoring: Regular supervision of high-risk patients, particularly those admitted to higher floors, should be mandatory.
2. Mental Health Counseling: In-house counselors and psychiatrists should be made available to address the emotional and mental health needs of patients.
3. Training for Staff: Medical staff should be trained to identify signs of mental distress and respond effectively.
4. Patient Safety Protocols: Installing safety measures like secure windows and controlled access to potentially hazardous areas can prevent impulsive actions by vulnerable patients.

Source of Information : https://health.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/hospitals/tb-patient-commits-suicide-at-hospital-in-ups-budaun-family-alleges-negligence/116045302

Subscribe TISHHA