FSSAI Must Act to Protect Consumers Concerns Over Added Sugar in Baby Food, In Recent concerns have emerged regarding the safety and transparency of food products in India, particularly those marketed as “health drinks” and baby foods. Dr. Arun Gupta, a paediatrician and convener of Nutrition Advocacy in Public Interest (NAPi), highlights the deceptive practices in food labeling and advertising that mislead consumers about nutritional content.
Image Source NAPi
Health Drink Labels Mislead Consumers
Renu Jain, a Bengaluru-based software professional and mother of two teenagers, experienced a wake-up call last year when she saw a viral video by Revant Himatsingka, known as “foodpharmer” on social media, warning about high sugar content in Bournvita. Jain, who had been giving Bournvita to her children for years, was shocked to learn that the drink, marketed as a health supplement, was high in sugar. This revelation raised questions about the authenticity of such products, which many families have trusted for decades.
The Challenge of Food Safety in India
India’s diverse and large population, with significant segments living in poverty and malnutrition, faces unique challenges in food safety and labeling. Civil society activists argue that even when robust policies are in place, the implementation is often weak. Dr. Gupta emphasizes that “health drink” labels often misrepresent the nutritional value, creating a misleading image of the product’s benefits.
Regulatory Delays and Misleading Advertisements
In April last year, the National Commission for Protection of Child Rights requested Mondelez International India to withdraw misleading advertisements for Bournvita. Despite this, it took almost a year for the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) to instruct e-commerce platforms to stop using the term “health drink” for malt-based products. The lack of a clear definition in food laws contributes to regulatory delays.
Concerns Over Added Sugar and Contaminated Spices
Issues extend beyond health drinks. Added sugar in baby food and contamination in spices have raised alarms among consumers. The FSSAI’s delayed responses and lack of stringent action have left many worried about the safety of their food. The FSSAI has not yet responded to queries regarding these concerns.
NAPi Report Reveals Deceptive Practices
A recent report by NAPi analyzed 50 advertisements for packaged food items and found that all of them concealed critical information about sugar, salt, and fat content. The report also highlighted the use of celebrities and attractive visuals to mislead consumers. This deceptive marketing contributes to rising rates of obesity, diabetes, and other diet-related illnesses in India.
Weak Enforcement and Regulatory Challenges
Despite reports of misleading advertisements, the Advertisement Monitoring Committee of FSSAI reported 32 cases of violations in May 2023. However, an RTI query revealed that no penalties had been imposed on these companies. Dr. Gupta criticizes the lack of objective definitions and effective enforcement mechanisms in the FSSAI Act 2006, which hampers the identification and punishment of misleading ads.
Global Food Security and India’s Ranking
India’s performance in global food safety rankings is also a concern. The Global Food Security Index 2022 ranked India 67th out of 113 countries in terms of food quality and safety. With India aspiring to be a developed nation by 2047, this ranking raises questions about the effectiveness of its food safety regulations.
Recent Initiatives by FSSAI
In response to these challenges, the FSSAI has introduced new initiatives. In July 2024, FSSAI approved a proposal to display nutritional information about sugar, salt, and saturated fat in bold letters on food labels. This amendment aims to empower consumers to make healthier choices and address rising non-communicable diseases (NCDs). However, some experts, like George Cheriyan, criticize the proposal as insufficient compared to more effective front-of-pack labeling systems used in other countries.
Challenges in Testing and Regulation
Testing food products for claims such as “trans fat-free” is another significant challenge. The World Health Organization (WHO) called for the elimination of industrially produced trans fats by 2023, but there are limited facilities to verify these claims. This gap in testing facilities undermines efforts to ensure food safety.
FSSAI was established in 2006 to regulate food safety and ensure wholesome consumption. Despite its creation following demands for better food laws, significant challenges remain. Food companies continue to market unhealthy products, and many consumers are unaware of the true nutritional content. It is crucial for FSSAI to strengthen its regulations and enforcement to protect public health and ensure transparency in food labeling. The responsibility should not solely rest on consumers; effective regulation and enforcement are essential to safeguard public health.
Join TISHHA.